Photoplay Cookbook: Gwen Lee’s Potato Omelet

Cook Header

Welcome back! I am cooking my way through the 1929 Photoplay cookbook (recipes of the stars!) and you are invited to tag along. (I have listed all the recipes I have tested on this dedicated page. Check back often.) Today, we will be testing a recipe from a starlet who supported many famous flappers in her day.

We’ve all heard of “that guy” actors: performers who don’t have name recognition but seem to show up everywhere. In the twenties, Gwen Lee was something of a “that gal” actress. She appeared in support of most of the big names at MGM, from Norma Shearer to Lon Chaney and also stepped out of the MGM ranks to appear alongside famed flappers Clara Bow and Colleen Moore.


Gwen Lee was born Gwendolyn Lepinski in Nebraska but she was Gwen Lee of Hollywood by the time she was twenty. She specialized in playing world-weary girls, often from the wrong side of the tracks. You can spot her in Lady of the Night, The Plastic Age and Laugh Clown Laugh, just to name a few of her silent supporting roles. Everything seemed ducky and she was named a WAMPAS Baby Star in 1928 but her career never quite ignited.

Lee’s parts got steadily smaller as the thirties wore on but you can still see her in uncredited parts in films like A Night at the Opera and Libeled Lady. Her last credited role was in 1938’s Paroled from the Big House.

So, we know that Miss Lee was a charming actress who never quite cracked the upper ranks but how are her omelet-making skills?


Well, there’s not much that can go wrong with potatoes, eggs and onions. Whether or not this can be considered a proper omelet is another matter. Like the great chili debate (beans? no beans?), I think it is wise that I steer clear of the controversy.

Anyway, here is the result:

Bubble, bubble
Bubble, bubble
It's losing containment!
It’s losing containment!
My omelet broke
My omelet broke
Yes, I do put cheese and ketchup on my eggs. Don't judge.
Yes, I do put cheese and ketchup on my eggs. Don’t judge.

Excuse the paper plates. I have a cold.

The taste test video:

My rating: 3 out of 5. The recipe is easy and the ingredient combination is edible. (If you think that isn’t an accomplishment, you clearly have not seen Joan Crawford’s Banana Salad.) The flavor combination is basic, even simplistic but you can do a lot to juice it up with salsa, hot sauce or ketchup.

The whole thing fell apart even before I attempted to flip it. I think perhaps the potatoes are too heavy for the egg to hold together. This might have been more successful in a tiny pan.

Improve it: I took a peek at potato omelet and modified frittata recipes and discovered a pattern. Many of these recipes fell into two basic categories. The first type was cooked on the stove-top and used a much, much higher proportion of egg to potato, usually at least two to one. The second type used a similar egg-to-potato proportion to Miss Lee’s recipe but baked the concoction in an oven-safe skillet. So, if you decide to make this recipe, use a lot more eggs or opt for baking.

On the other hand, I may just have terrible potato-omelet-flipping skills. Such is life.


  1. Michael Kuzmanovski

    I don’t know, it just seems like someone was set on eating their scrambled eggs and hashbrowns together and decided to create the potato omelet. At least it was pretty good.

  2. Coolsville

    Potatoes and eggs go great together! I love your celeb recipe posts. I may try this myself although I’d probably end up with a type of mash than an omelet. I’m not a swell omelet-flipper either! I tried scrambling eggs with Julienne-style (shredded) potatoes once, and that was pretty good.

    1. Fritzi Kramer

      Thank you! I think the recipe would probably have been more successful with julienned potatoes. I’m thinking either more of a potato pancake (smaller for easier flipping) or making the whole thing in an oven-proof skillet and baking are the two options with the most potential for success.

      1. geelw

        A nice cast iron skillet is the way to go here. I make a decent enough potato er, fritatta thingy (it can’t be called an omelet because I don’t flip them – a few minutes on the stove for the potatoes and onions to get done and finished under a broiler, nice and puffy). Still three potatoes and five eggs? That’s for what, six to eight people if you make it in a large enough pan?

        I’d add a half-handful of baby spinach after pouring in the eggs (and perhaps some garlic) before it all went into the oven along with some small cubes of cheese (munester, colby, pepper jack, gouda, etc.)… Annnnnd, I just made myself really hungry. 😀

      2. Fritzi Kramer

        Yes, I feel cheese would add a lot in terms of both flavor and structure.

        I served five with my pan but I also had side dishes (toast, etc.) so it depends on appetites and what goes with it.

Comments are closed.